|
|
--Geological Analysis
The faults and depositional character
of the deeper structures (Morrow and Bone Spring) provide the depositional
surface for the shallower sequences and creates the bench-step surface being
used to describe the Brushy Canyon reservoir. While the original concept
pictured the NDP as a collection of thin channel sands continuously distributed
between wells, the results from Phase I show the subzones within the sandstones
are lenticular and are not always continuous from well to well which can
affect flow paths between wells. The interpretations of the advanced reservoir
analysis show the oil accumulation in Brushy Canyon interval exists areally
as pods or fairways and vertically as stacked micro-reservoirs. Examination
of the core under ultraviolet light revealed the discontinuous character
of the hydrocarbon distribution mixed with water zones throughout the pay
interval. This correlates with the erratic vertical distribution of oil
and water saturations calculated from the log analysis. Details of the geological
analysis are included in the second annual progress report (Second
Annual) and in an AAPG paper (AAPG
Paper)
--Data Wells Drilled
In Phase I, six wells were
drilled to gather data, delineate the field, and evaluate completion
and production
techniques. Each of these wells was drilled in different areas of the
field to determine the producing characteristics at various field positions.
Conventional suites of logs and multiple sidewall cores were obtained
in all of the NDP data wells. In addition, 61.9 m (203 ft) of full core
was obtained from one new well and a magnetic resonance tool was run
for comparison to the core analysis. Basic core data were measured for
each
foot of core, and special core analysis were performed on the full core.
The core data were used to calibrate the logs and determine pay distribution
in each zone. A detailed core-calibrated log analysis of saturations
and porosity was applied to the digitized logs to determine the productive
and the water zones in each interval. The application of porosity/permeability
transforms and relative permeability data to each zone yielded flow
capacity
data for each interval. Details are given in the first annual technical
progress report (First
Annual).
--Advanced Log Analysis
To evaluate the highly laminated
micro-reservoirs that make up the pay zones in the Brushy Canyon interval,
a log evaluation technique was developed to identify pay that is laminated
with wet zones. Using transmissibility values to calculate production
from the various zones for all 16 wells in the NDP, results show that
while the bulk of the oil production at the NDP comes from the "L"
sandstone, much of the water is produced from the "K" and "K-2"
sandstone, if the latter zone is present. By properly identifying productive
pay intervals, oil recovery from the Brushy Canyon reservoir at the NDP
is calculated to be 16.6%, rather than the 10% as initially estimated.
This methodology for identifying net pay in complex reservoirs can be
applied in other highly laminated sandstone formations. The methodology,
outlined in the first annual report (First
Annual), was used to identify net pay and estimate flow capacity for
each interval (Second
Annual). The advanced log analysis technique is also described in
two SPE papers (SPE
Paper 38916) and (SPE
Paper 39775).
--Geophysical Results
Vertical seismic profiles and
a 3-D seismic survey were acquired to assist in interwell correlations
and facies prediction. By conducting pre-survey VSP wave testing and
by careful processing of 3-D seismic data, the thin-bed turbidite reservoirs
at the NDP could be imaged, and the individual Brushy Canyon sandstones
could be resolved. The interpreted seismic data indicated that the NDP
may be highly compartmentalized, and that some of the compartments, for
some sand sequences in the "L" zone, may be much smaller than
300 acres. Results of seismic data and other interpretations are being
used for targeted drilling in high-grade areas of the NDP. Seismic acquisition
is described in the first annual report (First
Annual Report) and seismic analysis is provided in the second
annual report (Second
Annual Report), and the results are discussed in two technical
papers (GEOPHYSICS
Papers). As new wells and data became available, interpretation
of the seismic results has continued (Fifth
Annual).
--Geostatistics and Seismic Attribute Analysis
The potential value of geostatistical
techniques for estimating interwell reservoir properties, with infill
drilling as a possible goal, was investigated. However, NDP wells primarily
cover the center part of the initial seismic survey, so a new technique
was developed to extrapolate reservoir properties beyond the area directly
constrained by wells. This new technique utilizes a non-linear multivariable
regression (Neural Networks) with seismic attributes as inputs and porosity,
water saturation, and net pay as outputs. A Fuzzy Ranking System can help
decide which seismic attributes are most useful for evaluating reservoir
properties. The regression equations allow the prediction of the three
reservoir properties in areas without direct well control, and the resulting
computed maps, such as hydrocarbon pore volume, can be generated fieldwide.
Results suggest that predictions of interwell and fieldwide reservoir
properties are possible Details of the methodology are available (Third
Annual Report) (SPE
Paper 56733).
--Reservoir Modeling and Simulation
After a fieldwide geological
model of the NDP was completed, a detailed simulation model of a proposed
pilot area (simulation
area) was developed for the most productive "L" sand (First
Annual Report). Reservoir simulation studies were performed to evaluate
various injection methods, including waterflooding, lean gas, and carbon
dioxide, for the pilot area (Second
& Third
Annual Reports). Immiscible gas injection for pressure maintenance
in the proposed pilot area at the NDP was ruled out because of low reservoir
pressure and compartmentalization of productive intervals. The low permeabilities
and relative permeability effects may preclude waterflooding at the NDP.
Miscible CO2 flooding may be a viable method at the NDP, and areas of
the field already under production could be candidates for miscible CO2
injection, but a low-cost source of the gas is not available in the vicinity
of the NDP. Injection of immiscible hydrocarbon gas for pressure maintenance
may be viable in undeveloped regions if those areas are not pressure depleted
or compartmentalized and if injection is initiated early. The results
of the reservoir studies prompted the decision to shift consideration
of a pressure maintenance pilot project into Phase 2, when new areas of
the NDP are drilled.
--Technology Transfer Activities
Technology Transfer of the data
and results from the NDP project have been a major component of the project.
All of the technology transfer activities are listed in the major section
in Technology Transfer (Technology
Transfer). Interest in this project has been high and the application
of results from the project has been useful in other Delaware fields.
The transfer of technology from Phase 2 will continue to be a major component
of the project.
--Modified Plans
The original Statement of Work included a pressure maintenance pilot project
in a developed area of the field. The proposed pressure maintenance injection
was not conducted because the pilot area was pressure depleted, and the seismic
results suggest the pilot area is compartmentalized. Because reservoir discontinuities
would reduce the effectiveness of any injection scheme, the pilot area will
be reconsidered in Phase 2 of the project if a more continuous part of the reservoir
can be located that has sufficient reservoir pressure.
The major emphasis in Phase 2 is to use the advanced characterization results
to design extended-reach/horizontal wells to tap into predicted "sweet
spots" that are inaccessible with conventional vertical wells.
|